By Sasha - 16 Feb 2012

Calm Down, Guys

It seems as if a lot of men get really upset when feminists talk about gender-inequity. We point out sexist language and misogynist ideas in society that people have internalized and we say they’re not cool. We talk about privilege and ask that people be aware of the unearned privilege they might have and take that into account. Then we get told that we’re overreacting and need to calm the fuck down and stop being so emotional. Well, I don’t get told I’m being emotional, because I’m a man and “everyone knows” men are the rational ones. (Did you know that the stereotype used to be flipped? Men were capable of robust emotion and women were coldly calculating and rational.)

Here’s the thing: unless you start being an asshole I’m not trying to make you feel like a crappy person. We’re all forced into this system and we have to reason our way out of it. Just like many of us reject the “common sense” arguments for religious belief and then we ask questions and gather information and draw a conclusion. Your average theist isn’t stupid or evil, they just haven’t done the work or had that “deconversion” moment. When you start kicking and screaming and throwing temper tantrums because someone has challenged your assumptions what does that make you? Does that make you a free-thinker? A skeptic?  No, it makes you a tradition-bound and close-minded person who is being willfully ignorant. When you reject new information because it is inconvenient (or because maybe you just don’t trust women, perhaps) then you become an asshole.

I am a student of history and what I see in our communities, especially online, reminds me of two things. In the early 20th century women marching for their right to vote were insulted, abused, and beaten to silence them. People who were comfortable with the status quo attempted to silence them through threats and force. When you attempt to shout down a woman who criticizes what you assume is “working just fine” you are not physically assaulting her but you’re very obviously attempting to silence to. To make her and the other feminists go away so that you can stay in your traditional way of life. Is that how you see yourself? Is that how you want to be? How does that make you different from a homophobic Baptist preacher?

I am also reminded of the creationists attempt to argue that their handful of scientists trumps our flood of experts saying that evolution is fact. Anti-feminists like to bring out a few women as token “experts” to say “No, really dudes, it’s just fine by me and I speak for all women ever!” Compare that to the chorus of women who say there is a problem and things need to improve. The comfortable nature of an answer doesn’t make it any less false. It’s true that, since they are people, women have diverse experiences and opinions. No one woman speaks for all women. There are some women who feel perfectly content with things as they are. Does that mean that you should ignore the hundreds who aren’t for every one of them?

I’m all over the place today, but I guess what I’m trying to say is calm the fuck down. We’re not attacking you personally until you start being a bag of shit about things and refusing to revise your opinion in the face of new information. Start being a skeptic and stop being horrible. Thanks, I appreciate your help.

– Sasha Pixlee

Promote Post

3 Comments

BelethFebruary 16, 2012 10:27 am

I’d summarize what I took away from this post as “You’re not a horrible man, you horrible man.”

I understand that you’re not *trying* to make me feel like a crappy person… but you do anyway.

Sasha February 16 2012 10:36 am

I definitely don't want to alienate potential men. My point with this post (which I *think* you got) was that you and I are not horrible just because of how the world behaves right now. The people who *are* horrible are those who fight to maintain an intolerable situation. I certainly hope you don't find yourself identifying with the latter group.

It's okay to feel a little defensive when it's pointed out to you that you have been swimming in a sea of unearned awesomeness. What's not okay is to then deny that you have those privileges or to fight to protect them at the expense of others.

duckysamFebruary 16, 2012 7:04 pm

It’s amazing how guilty people feel about their privilege.

I just posted something to my blog that I reposted from another blog of mine… yeah. This, if you’re interested. http://feministatheist.blogspot.com/2012/02/i-dont-want-you-to-feel-guilty.html

Please note: we are not hosted by wordpress.com and as such your WordPress username/password will not work on More than Men.
Please register for an account to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

http://www.morethanmen.org/wp-content/themes/selecta